海角社区

Provost's Leadership Team Presentation

At a recent meeting of the Provost’s Leadership Team (PLT) I had the chance to discuss the Department Cornerstone Course program that the CTLD started a year ago. I worked to give them context about how course-development projects have worked in the past and what makes Department Cornerstone projects different. The most important part was getting these leaders to grapple with what really should be part of our top-notch courses.

A key part of what makes the Department Cornerstone program different is the Cornerstone Framework, a set of course design choices and facilitation methods that come from scholarly research on this question: “How do different instructional designs, tools, facilitation and teaching methods impact student DFW rates, retention, engagement, and sense of community?”

I asked these leaders to wrestle with some of the Framework standards. To get the most out of this short piece, I’m going to ask you to do the same.


Commit Before You Scroll

First, follow this link:

This is a quick 4-question form. Committing some answers first will increase the impact and retention of what comes next (this is one of the key ideas behind Peer Instruction [1]).


History: CTLD "Classic" Projects and the QM "Health Code"

In 2016, 海角社区’s HLC visit forced us to consider quality assurance around our online courses. 海角社区 leaders at that time estimated that just 10% of our online courses reflected best practices, and that there were many easy-but-empty courses that “typically result in high average grade point averages across student enrollees and have positive student survey results due to the ease of accomplishing course expectations. These courses do not meet HLC nor federal financial guidelines for distance (online) education.” [2]

Seeing these problems, a new fee was proposed, called the Online Education Program Fee (OEP Fee) and it was passed by students in 2019. Students agreed to pay an additional fee per credit hour for every online course, part of which would go to improving online courses. In that process, each course would be checked using Quality Matters (QM), “the most well-established standard for the design and development of online courses.” [2]

A Quality Matters course review revolves around an extensive set of criteria that are similar to a “health code” for online courses. Some of the most basic are making sure students are told how to get tech support, or that a grading policy is clearly stated. In the creation of the new fee, 海角社区 promised that course development efforts would now have a guaranteed minimum quality, embodied first by the QM standards and later by a set of faculty-written 海角社区 Online Course Design Standards (OCDS). Since that time, all course-development projects with the CTLD include a pre- and post-development review using both of these rubrics.

A sampling of 28 courses from the two 2025 design cycles, showing the pre- and post-development QM review scores. Initial scores range from 10-92. Final scores are almost all 100%, with a few 98.


Persistent Problems

But just like a restaurant, passing the health code doesn’t guarantee excellent food or a wonderful experience. In the DFW Playbook work that began in early 2025, departments identified high-enrollment, often multi-section courses that remain stubbornly problematic. Some of these had been through the “classic” CTLD course-development cycle (some multiple times) and yet there are clear signs that something isn’t working. Students aren’t succeeding in these courses the way we hope, the results are worse for online sections, and dismal for first-year students. When departments asked to work with the CTLD on these courses, we developed the Department Cornerstone Course program.


How Cornerstones Are Different

Different Support

A Department Cornerstone Course represents the largest investment 海角社区 has ever made in improving a course, with a 4-term commitment. First, it only happens with the buy in of a whole department, including the chair, two faculty design partners (called “Pillars”) and the agreement of other key faculty that teach the course. The two faculty Pillars each get reassigned time for the design phase as well as small stipends for their ongoing work. CTLD staff contribute about 600 hours of support over 4 terms. Cornerstone funds pay adopting faculty to attend onboarding events each semester (with food). And real data on implementation and impact is collected so we can decide if the program works.

Different Process

Instead of focusing only on the design phase, as happens in a “classic” CTLD project, the Cornerstone process includes making actionable plans for how ideas will be shared among faculty, how implementation data will be gathered, and how continuous improvement will happen. For example, each Cornerstone design shows adopting faculty a “flexibility map” that identifies the content, assignments, policies, and teaching moves that can and cannot be changed by each instructor. The project includes support in trying to create a community of practice around each course. And data collection is more nuanced than reviewing the blunt numbers like DFW rates and student ratings.

Different Standards

Lastly, we come back to the Cornerstone Framework, a set of standards in 5 categories that tries to describe what makes a course truly excellent, improving student DFW rates, retention, engagement, and sense of community.

  • Category 1: Course Structure, Organization & Transparency
  • Category 2: Assessment Design & Grading for Persistence
  • Category 3: Feedback & Instructor Presence
  • Category 4: Interaction, Engagement & Active Learning
  • Category 5: Recovery, Support & Intervention

Back to Your Answers

Now, let’s revisit the questions you answered on the form at the start of this piece.

Reveal #1: Recovery from early setbacks

First, consider standard 5.2: “In a Cornerstone Course, the syllabus / course information should detail how students can revise, resubmit, or otherwise recover from early setbacks.”

In our Framework, this is a required strategy for any Cornerstone course. Remember that to be in this program, a course has already been identified as having persistent student success problems, after which the department and university have agreed to invest heavily in improving the course. After months of work by a collaborative team, a recovery strategy like this is a must-have. Of the students that have these early setbacks, only a few will be able to take advantage of the recovery path, but those few are exactly the ones we want to help get back on track.

Reveal #2: The odd one out

The second question used the following Cornerstone Framework standards:

  • 1.6 – All course policies governing grading, late work, attendance, participation, and student conduct are clearly and thoroughly described within the course shell
  • 2.1 – A required, graded, academically meaningful task by the census date
  • 2.8 – Participation is integrated into graded assessments rather than measured through attendance
  • 3.3 – Meaningful instructor presence must be explicitly evident to students within the first quarter of the course

In this case, the odd one out was 2.8, which is only recommended in the Framework. While the research is clear that meaningful, graded work is a better way to track attendance or participation, it isn’t always possible to do so.

Reveal #3: All about facilitation

Finally, consider the four standards from the last question:

  • 5.1 – A course-specific intervention plan with checkpoint dates and triggers
  • 3.2 – Timely, actionable feedback before major summative assessments
  • 3.5 – Instructor outreach to at-risk students at least quarterly
  • 3.1 – Defined expectations for instructor response time and communication method

All four of these are Required parts of the Cornerstone Framework, but the main reason I brought these to the attention of the PLT (and to you) was to point out that all four are about how the teaching and facilitation of the course happens during the semester. The design of the course can influence these heavily, but ultimately it is the actions of each individual instructor that determine whether these actually happen. Standards like these are where we draw the line and say that “fully automated” courses are not what students deserve to get when they attend 海角社区.


An Assertive Framework - The Right Kind of Friction

Instructional designers and faculty development staff have an odd position in most universities: They are not in charge of course quality and aren’t involved in oversight of faculty, but they are experts in course design and andragogy in the same way faculty are experts in their fields. For good reason, the CTLD has spent years being careful not to tell faculty what they must do, with only a few exceptions, such as accessibility and copyright.

So let me name the worry out loud: the thing that makes Department Cornerstone projects different, true requirements, is also the thing most likely to strain and damage our collaborative partnerships with faculty. My hope is that when faculty understand the research basis of the Framework, and the way it will serve our students, they will see why this collaboration has to be different.

This is an experimental shift for the CTLD. The Framework has substantive requirements that force genuinely uncomfortable conversations. Faculty pillars, instructional designers, adopting instructors, department chairs, and faculty development staff have to grapple together with what this kind of course must guarantee to the students. When both the department and university have invested this heavily in a course that keeps failing students, we have to have the courage to move beyond doing what we’ve always done. The discomfort in these conversations is the productive friction that accompanies growth and change.


For Your Consideration

So, to the extent that you have both time and appetite, I invite you to look carefully at the (v2, Sept 2026). Some questions you might ask yourself as you look at these:

  1. If you taught an online course that met all the “Required” standards, do you think it would change students’ success in the course?
  2. Think back to the first time you taught a key intro course in your department. If you had been onboarded into a design that met these standards, and brought into a community of practice around that course, how would that have mattered?
  3. Are there some items in the Framework that you think should actually be required for all courses at 海角社区, rather than just for courses that meet the narrow criteria of a Department Cornerstone project?

If any of those are thought provoking for you, I would love to hear your feedback. Let me buy you coffee, or at least shoot me an email.


Notes and Disclosures

Notes:

  1. For more on Peer Instruction, see from the University of Michigan鈥檚 Center for Research on Learning and Teaching. The core move is to have students commit to an answer individually, then discuss with a peer before answering again.
  2. Online Enrollment Fee Proposal from 2018. CTLD records, available on request.

Logo with brain and circuit imagery, plus the text "+AI," in 海角社区 Colors.Generative AI disclosure:

I did extensive back and forth chats with Claude about how I wanted to translate my PLT talk into a Connections piece.聽None of the text or ideas is AI-generated, but it was helpful for figuring out what I wanted to do and then for formatting within WordPress.

After writing this piece I used generative AI to write a first draft of the short 鈥渢easer blurb鈥� that went out by email. Want to know more? Send me an email and we can chat!